"BRING THEM HOME NOW" TOUR BRINGS HATE TO THE STATE CAPITOL
Ellison also couldn't resist using the word "looting" in his speech.
##
War protesters link Iraq, Katrina
Under an "Impeach Bush" banner on a wall of the Minnesota State Capitol, anti-war speakers tried Saturday to link the Iraq war to a slow response to Hurricane Katrina.
It was part of the "Bring Them Home Now" national bus tour initiated by Cindy Sheehan, the mother who camped near President Bush's Texas ranch to demand that he talk with her about the death of her soldier son.
Sheehan was in the South on another bus Saturday, but about 350 people showed up in St. Paul to hear out-of-state speakers, along with local legislators, candidates and clergy members decry the war and question the president's moral values in waging it.
Several speakers suggested victims of Hurricane Katrina would have been better off had National Guard forces, and the money used to send the troops to Iraq, been here to help them.
"People are dying in Louisiana and New Orleans right now" because Bush, a "warmonger," is intent on "looting" oil in Iraq, said state Rep. Keith Ellison, DFL-Minneapolis.
After the rally, representatives of several military families held a news conference nearby to say troops need to stay in Iraq to support the war against terrorism and a future for the Iraqi people.
Kelly Freudenberg, of Forest Lake, whose soldier son was buried Friday, later disagreed with a link between Iraq and slowness of hurricane relief.
"Maybe that's where the people who are here have to step up to the plate," said Freudenberg, whose son, Pfc. Elden D. Arcand, was killed last month in Iraq. "Do our troops have to do everything? ... Do we always have to depend on the government to provide everything?
"There are still young people today joining the Army, just like Elden, with their eyes wide open" because they believe in the cause, she said. "People still believe in the war," and it may take a generation or two to create an Iraqi government that won't be overthrown.
Litany of complaints
The anti-war rally was held amid a display of white crosses, empty black military boots and signs such as "Bush lied / thousands died."
Speakers cited a litany of complaints, including lack of training, equipment and medical care for troops and costs they said could reach $1.3 trillion.
The war is "immoral, illegal, irrational," said the Rev. Lowell Erdahl, bishop emeritus of the St. Paul Area Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America.
Other speakers included Dave Foster, district director of the United Steelworkers of America, veteran anti-war activist Polly Mann, and two women who had been with Sheehan in Texas: state Sen. Becky Lourey, DFL-Kerrick, whose son was killed in Iraq, and Coleen Rowley, the former FBI agent who is running for the DFL nomination for Congress in the Second District.
Several speakers stressed support for the troops but not the war.
However, Kathy Dunaway, of Forest Lake, one of the counter-protesters, disagreed. "How can you support an individual who is laying their life on the line for their country and the Iraqi people, and not support the cause?" she said.
The counterprotesters are part of a national effort by Operation Iraqi Hope, based in Austin, Texas, that seeks to dispute the message of the Sheehan supporters. Source: Star Tribune, September 3, 2005




8 Comments:
Well, Coleen Rowley's political career died yesterday. At an event that they couldn't get hardly any elected officials to attend (and lend their credibility to), she jumped in head first.
You'll recall that when going to Texas she said something about this being more general support for her, not supporting everything the group down their supported.
But here she is giving her name and "credibility" to them here, too. That's not "general support", that's complete and utter support of every wacko statement Sheehan made. Rowley needs to be linked forever to those statements.
You'll also note who didn't show up. To my knowledge you didn't see any major players there. Why? Because they know that most people think this group is a bunch of wackos.
Once again those on the right turn to name calling.
Well, when the left is so unwilling (or maybe unable?) to actually intellectually discuss issues then maybe the right will have something to do besides name call. But all we ever hear from the left is blind hatred (witness the post-hurricane blame game) so if anyone is bringing down the level of depate in this country, it aint us.
Once again those on the right turn to name calling.
What in the world are you talking about? What name calling?
Trinhmaster said...
Once again those on the right turn to name calling.
I think Trinhamster is talking about calling the socialist left wackos...and it's probably because s/he doesn't have any other response.
If that's the best he can do, that's pretty weak. What I said was:
That's not "general support", that's complete and utter support of every wacko statement Sheehan made.
I called their statements wacko, not Cindy.
Of course, she is a wacko leftie extremist but I didn't call her one in that post.
At least if you're going to accuse me of namecalling be sure I'm actually doing it.
John Jordan said at 11:02am
At least if you're going to accuse me of namecalling be sure I'm actually doing it.
John Jordan said at 6:51am
You'll also note who didn't show up. To my knowledge you didn't see any major players there. Why? Because they know that most people think this group is a bunch of wackos.
:P
Hey talking about who didn't show up...there were only three counterprotesters. It must be true that everyone loves a winner. The minority counter movement must be having trouble mustering support. What's that you say? You can fool so of the people...
One of the three counterprotesters said he didn't enlist because his mom wouldn't allow him. Of course at 25 yrs old that's more than a little weak. Still, you've got to respect a foul mouthed guy who spews hate 95% of the time he opens his mouth, but still listens to mom!
Post a Comment
<< Home